The New Orleans Saints suffered a demoralizing loss to the Carolina Panthers in a game in which they were positioned to compete for first place in the NFC South. Over the first three quarters, a lot of the same issues popped up that have plagued the team since the beginning of the season and beyond.
The grades reflect those elements. The Saints’ defense, which performed well for the vast majority of the contest, graded highly, with the offense either falling into the middle of the scale or toward the bottom after not being able to take advantage of a favorable set up.
Here are the highest- and lowest-graded players from Sunday’s game, per Pro Football Focus (minimum 20 snaps):
Highest-Graded
- S Jonas Sanker – 84.1
- LB Kaden Elliss – 80.0
- EDGE Carl Granderson – 76.1
- EDGE Chase Young – 74.9
- LG David Edwards – 74.1
Sanker’s two pass break ups and good work in coverage allowed him to overcome a pair of missed tackles that were credited against him. The STAR/slot defender has been dedicating extra time to developing as a coverage player and it’s clearly paying off. While New Orleans failed to stop running back Chuba Hubbard, it fared very well against the Panthers’ pass-catchers.
Elliss, Granderson and Young continue to be bright spots for the team. They’ve been the club’s most consistent performers outside of wide receiver Chris Olave, but can’t be gameplanned against as a trio the way Olave can be gameplanned against as the team’s sole offensive option. That is, until rookie wideout Jordyn Tyson captures more attention. It’s a race to see who will end the season with more sacks between Young and Granderson while Elliss continues to set the tone in the second level.
Edwards and left tackle Kelvin Banks Jr. performed well on the left side of the offensive line. The Panthers, unsurprisingly, attacked the weakened right side often throughout the matchup. Edwards was created with only one pressure surrendered in a game in which quarterback Tyler Shough spent more than a third of his dropbacks under pressure.
Lowest-Graded
- RG Jeremiah Wright – 24.3
- TE Noah Fant – 28.8
- DT Nathan Shepherd – 38.9
- RB Audric Estime – 44.5
- CB Martin Emerson Jr. – 45.5
On the flip side of Edwards, the rookie Wright struggled. The first-year protector was credited with four pressures, including two of the three sacks the team surrendered. He also didn’t grade out well as a run blocker, which was considered his strength coming into the league. Carolina did a solid job making things uncomfortable for the right side of the line.
Shepherd and Emerson both graded out poorly as run defenders and tacklers with Emerson missing a tackle and Shepherd credited with three misses. Because Emerson did not record a tackle in the game, he clocked a 100% missed tackle rate while Shepherd notched a 60% rate.
Fant recorded the Saints’ only drop of the game on his lone target and graded low as arun blocker while Estime gained just six rushing yards on seven carries after being consistently contacted behind the line of scrimmage on his rushes.