PALMER: What ramifications will LSU face for playing Luis?


Mitchell Scaglione/LSU/University Images via Getty Images

The tug-of-war for sole possession of the proverbial black hat continues on LSU’s campus.

Lane Kiffin is under fire for his team’s fourth loss, and Will Wade managed to sully any positive national coverage of the team’s win over Gonzaga by rostering RJ Luis on Monday and playing him Wednesday night.

The talking heads bristled. Attorneys general and anonymous sources voiced their displeasure on and off the record. Expulsion from the league and potential boycotts were once again talking points instead of the games on the court.

It’s clear Wade doesn’t care.

During his first run in Baton Rouge, the NCAA cloud covered Wade from his second year onward after the FBI heard him on a tapped phone conversation. That “damn strong offer” comment and the investigation that followed eventually cost him his job.

Very few truly care about players receiving impermissible benefits a decade ago. It’s now legal, and Wade’s image was partially repaired by taking McNeese to the NCAA Tournament twice and resurfacing at NC State.

His departure from Raleigh, N.C., was a bit sloppy, but he preferred the LSU job and called it home when he was announced as the head man in Baton Rouge for the second time. Folks hated him on Tobacco Road, but nationally, it was a minor story that got lost in the news cycle.

Three games into his second LSU tenure, his team’s win over a ranked Gonzaga team was the headline of the college basketball weekend. With football season roaring toward the College Football Playoff, I’d hesitate to call it a national headline, but it got plenty of positive attention from national outlets focused on college basketball.

That’s all gone.

The truth is that I don’t know what will come of all this. By my eyes, a bunch of attorneys are making money billing hours. Between temporary restraining orders, federal lawsuits, preliminary injunctions, public statements, press releases, angry judges, outspoken politicians and cocky lawyers, I don’t see a lot of progress.

I see a bunch of actionless verbiage and paperwork while the cash register rings.

Perhaps Luis plays the season under the injunction and LSU has a damn strong season. He moves on to his next step, LSU overhauls the roster again and it’s all forgotten. Perhaps the injunction is overturned and Luis goes the way of Charles Bediako of Alabama a year ago and becomes a blip on the radar.

Neither of those outcomes move the needle.

The preliminary injunction currently says the SEC cannot punish LSU for rostering Luis. He’s eligible. The SEC gave its written word that it would abide by that court ruling.

I’m not savvy enough from a legal sense to know whether or not a punishment can come should another judge rule him ineligible at some point in the future. If the SEC wins in federal court, can the league wield its sharpened axe beyond a Baton Rouge ruling?

What does that look like?

Forfeiture of games? A bummer, but not a big deal in the grand scheme. I realize that’s easy for me to say when I’m not a senior on the team playing my final basketball season.

Suspending the coach? Wade already missed two of his team’s NCAA Tournaments last time around. That’s almost business as usual around here.

It’s the threats beyond that that appear messy and potentially damaging in the long term.

Does LSU really just want to shrug if seven or eight basketball opponents decide not to show up? Does LSU want angry presidents and athletic directors to take a vote on LSU’s conference membership? Over RJ Luis? More on that later.

My livelihood isn’t on the line if LSU loses games. Wade’s is. I get that his sole focus is winning basketball games. And he’s clearly comfortable bending rules and exploring loopholes. I just feel like there’s a bigger picture to explore here than Luis’s 14 points per game in 2026-27.

LSU has torched its relationship with the current SEC office. That office controls scheduling, kickoff times, voting rights and myriad issues across all sports.

What’s more important, Luis or league affairs?

I will reject any suggestion that the SEC will expel LSU over this. A century of history trumps bad blood between Sankey, Wade, Kiffin and Gov. Jeff Landry. Give it a decade, and they’ll probably all be gone.

LSU-Alabama, LSU-Ole Miss and LSU-Auburn will not.

For some reason, players returning from American professional organizations became the biggest problem in the SEC’s view. It trumped academic fraud, criminal investigations, European professionals coming over, faking injuries, tampering and whatever else you want to add to the list.

This is the hill the league wants to die on.

Unlike Kiffin two months ago, Wade, the LSU legal team and the administration ran up the hill with a rifle and decided to fight.

Once Luis stepped on that court, the battle lines were drawn. There are dozens of athletes with professional experience on rosters around the country, but the spotlight is shining directly on LSU.

Good thing Wade has that hat.

Hunt Palmer

Hunt Palmer Show – Host