It was a light slate, but that didn’t mean the day was any less entertaining. There were dramatic finishes from the first games to the last. The week known as cupcake week wasn’t really weak at all. It gave us more answers than questions, and that’s not something that every week has provided this college football regular season.
Here are the three biggest instant overreactions to Week 12.
1. The finger-pointing in Baton Rouge may be the biggest issue of all for LSU
That may be dramatic and a bit of a stretch, but the point of the exercise is overreacting. There are a lot of issues with this year’s LSU team. It feels like after the first loss to Ole Miss, it was about the coaching and a slow start. After the Kentucky loss, it was about the defense. After the three consecutive losses in November, the fans and media have set their sights on Sam Leavitt.
I have no idea if Leavitt is going to return. I personally think he would improve in Year 2, but I also admittedly don’t know if that hypothetical improvement would even be enough to take LSU to a level at which it can win and meet the expectations that come with hiring Lane Kiffin. That being said, the amount of finger-pointing happening in Baton Rouge isn’t doing anyone any favors.
Sam Leavitt hasn’t been great, but let’s not forget that this is a quarterback that Kiffin sprinted to the Knoxville airport in desperation for, like some final scene in a Christmas rom-com convincing him not to go to better weather in Miami. Leavitt has had plenty of issues this season. But the blame for this season should fall on the shoulders of the person at the top. That’s the person that saw all of his film and decided to pay him nearly $5 million to come here. Remember, there’s not a quarterback who’s ever failed in a Kiffin offense like this. Some of it has to fall elsewhere. Kiffin and the offensive line are a good place to start.
2. Do we owe the CFP selection committee an apology?
We’ve sat here for weeks yelling into the clouds and our television sets about the CFP rankings and how dumb this committee is with its rankings. And while it’s absurd that they’ve continued to vault Alabama into the top three for the last two weeks, maybe the rest of their rankings, especially the ones for Indiana and UCLA, were valid.
Undefeated UCLA lost to a bad Michigan team. The defending national champion Indiana Hoosiers lost to a 6-4 Washington team on the road. The Big Ten had a terrible day for its contenders. As for the SEC, Alabama, Texas and Tennessee all had impressive wins by double digits. The idea that some sort of SEC bias is factored into the rankings and the CFP selection committee will never go away at this point. That being said, results on the field have to matter. That’s what the Big Ten contingent has been screaming for the last three seasons after all.
3. Get rid of Matt Austin in the booth
This is the most low-stakes, dumb complaint I’ve had all year, to be honest, but hear me out since it’s cupcake week.
Matt Austin has to go. I’m not saying he needs to lose his job because I wouldn’t wish that on anyone. But what is the point of having a rules analyst in the booth of every broadcast if he’s almost always wrong? He’s not a meteorologist predicting tomorrow’s weather forecast. He’s the rules expert.
He’s there to analyze and explain the rules of the game we are all watching. So if that’s the role, then someone explain to me how 80% of the time he’s on air, his analysis of the rule and prediction of what the call will be are wrong.