Coming off his First Team All Pro selection in 2024, former LSU star Derek Stingley, Jr., is among the betting favorites to be named Defensive Player of the Year in 2025. With 60/1 odds, the Houston Texans cornerback is among the top 20 players in the league considered for next season’s top honor.
Danielle Hunter (100/1) and Patrick Queen (150/1) are also on the list.
We don’t know where Myles Garrett will play next season, but that doesn’t seem to matter in BetOnline.ag opening Defensive Player of the Year odds for next season.
In addition to Myles Garrett, the oddsmakers have added a bunch of upcoming rookies including Travis Hunter and Abdul Carter.
The odds below are fluid and subject to change. Here’s the direct link to real-time lines: https://betonline.ag/sportsbook/futures-and-props/nfl-player-futures/defensive-player-of-the-year.
| 2025-25 NFL Defensive Player of the Year | ||
| Myles Garrett | 6/1 | |
| Aidan Hutchinson | 13/2 | (+650) |
| T.J. Watt | 15/2 | (+750) |
| Micah Parsons | 8/1 | |
| Will Anderson Jr. | 10/1 | |
| Nick Bosa | 16/1 | |
| Maxx Crosby | 16/1 | |
| Jalen Carter | 18/1 | |
| Jared Verse | 250/1 | |
| Patrick Surtain II | 28/1 | |
| Trey Hendrickson | 28/1 | |
| Quinyon Mitchell | 50/1 | |
| Kyle Hamilton | 50/1 | |
| Josh Hines_Allen | 50/1 | |
| Cooper DeJean | 50/1 | |
| Christian Gonzalez | 50/1 | |
| Fred Warner | 60/1 | |
| Derek Stingley Jr. | 60/1 | |
| Chris Jones | 60/1 | |
| Nik Bonitto | 60/1 | |
| Trent McDuffie | 66/1 | |
| Leonard Williams | 75/1 | |
| Nolan Smith | 75/1 | |
| George Karlaftis | 75/1 | |
| Dexter Lawrence II | 75/1 | |
| Zack Baun | 75/1 | |
| Will McDonald IV | 75/1 | |
| Rashan Gary | 100/1 | |
| Quinnen Williams | 100/1 | |
| Nnamdi Madubuike | 100/1 | |
| Montez Sweat | 100/1 | |
| Khalil Mack | 100/1 | |
| Kerby Joseph | 100/1 | |
| Jonathan Greenard | 100/1 | |
| Jaylon Johnson | 100/1 | |
| Marlon Humphrey | 100/1 | |
| Greg Rousseau | 100/1 | |
| Edgerrin Cooper | 100/1 | |
| Chop Robinson | 100/1 | |
| Devon Witherspoon | 100/1 | |
| Derwin James Jr. | 100/1 | |
| Demarcus Lawrence | 100/1 | |
| Danielle Hunter | 100/1 | |
| Budda Baker | 100/1 | |
| Brian Burns | 100/1 | |
| Brian Branch | 100/1 | |
| Bradley Chubb | 100/1 | |
| Xavier McKinney | 100/1 | |
| Andrew Van Ginkel | 100/1 | |
| Abdul Carter | 100/1 | |
| Trevon Diggs | 150/1 | |
| Travon Walker | 150/1 | |
| Travis Hunter | 150/1 | |
| Terrion Arnold | 150/1 | |
| Tarheeb Still | 150/1 | |
| Stephon Gilmore | 150/1 | |
| Sam Hubbard | 150/1 | |
| Roquan Smith | 150/1 | |
| Patrick Queen | 150/1 | |
| Nick Bolton | 150/1 | |
| Minkah Fitzpatrick | 150/1 | |
| Matthew Judon | 150/1 | |
| Leonard Floyd | 150/1 | |
| Laiatu Latu | 150/1 | |
| Kyle Van Noy | 150/1 | |
| Kobie Turner | 150/1 | |
| Kayvon Thibodeaux | 150/1 | |
| Joey Bosa | 150/1 | |
| Jessie Bates III | 150/1 | |
| Jeffrey Simmons | 150/1 | |
| Jaycee Horn | 150/1 | |
| Ja’Whaun Bentley | 150/1 | |
| Mykel Williams | 150/1 | |
| Nate Wiggins | 150/1 | |
| Javon Hargrave | 150/1 | |
| Jalen Ramsey | 150/1 | |
| Jaire Alexander | 150/1 | |
| Jaelan Phillips | 150/1 | |
| Jadeveon Clowney | 150/1 | |
| Ivan Pace Jr. | 150/1 | |
| Harold Landry III | 150/1 | |
| Josh Sweat | 150/1 | |
| Haason Reddick | 150/1 | |
| Jabrill Peppers | 150/1 | |
| Frankie Luvu | 150/1 | |
| Byron Murphy II | 150/1 | |
| Denzel Ward | 150/1 | |
| Antoine Winfield Jr. | 150/1 | |
| Alim McNeil | 150/1 | |
| DeForest Buckner | 150/1 | |
| Alex Highsmith | 150/1 | |
| David Onyemata | 150/1 | |
| Daron Payne | 150/1 | |
| DaRon Bland | 150/1 | |
| Dante Fowler Jr. | 150/1 | |
| Dallas Turner | 150/1 | |
| D.J. Reed | 150/1 | |
| Christian Wilkins | 150/1 | |
| Cameron Heyward | 150/1 | |
| Za’Darius Smith | 150/1 | |
| Braden Fiske | 150/1 | |
| Boye Mafe | 150/1 | |
| Zach Sieler | 150/1 | |
| Bobby Wagner | 150/1 | |
| Zach Allen | 150/1 | |
| Yaya Diaby | 150/1 | |
| Bobby Okereke | 150/1 | |
| Ahmad Gardner | 150/1 | |
| Will Johnson | 150/1 | |
| Walter Nolen | 150/1 | |
| Von Miller | 150/1 | |
| Vita Vea | 150/1 | |
| Mason Graham | 200/1 | |
| L’Jarius Sneed | 200/1 | |
| Keion White | 200/1 | |
| Justin Simmons | 200/1 | |
| Talanoa Hufanga | 200/1 | |
| T.J. Edwards | 200/1 | |
| Samson Ebukam | 200/1 | |
| Nakobe Dean | 200/1 | |
| Marshon Lattimore | 200/1 | |
| Malik Mustapha | 200/1 | |
| Kool-Aid McKinstry | 200/1 | |
| Kenny Moore II | 200/1 | |
| Kenny Clark | 200/1 | |
| Kamari Lassiter Jr. | 200/1 | |
| Joey Porter Jr | 200/1 | |
| Jack Campbell | 200/1 | |
| Evan Williams | 200/1 | |
| Dre Greenlaw | 200/1 | |
| Ed Oliver | 200/1 | |
| Chavarius Ward | 200/1 | |
| C.J. Mosley | 200/1 | |
| C.J. Gardner-Johnson | 200/1 | |
| Demario Davis | 200/1 | |
| Cameron Jordan | 200/1 | |
| Zaven Collins | 200/1 | |
| Zaire Franklin | 200/1 | |
| Riq Woolen | 200/1 | |
| AJ Epenesa | 200/1 | |
| Darius Slay | 250/1 | |
| Andru Phillips | 250/1 | |
| Jalon Walker | 300/1 | |
| Damar Hamlin | 300/1 | |
| Mike Green | 500/1 | |
